Navigate:

Advice
Beginners
BIOS Guide
CPUs
Links
Mainboards
Memory
Network
Storage
Video/Sound Cards

Contact
Forum
SiteMap
Sponsors
WebNews
Home
. .

Prices:
CPU
Intel
P4 2.4C-800
P4 2.6C-800
P4 2.8C-800
P4 3.0-800
P4 3.2-800

AMD
AthlonXP
XP 1700+
XP 2000+
XP 2400+
XP 2500+
XP 2700+
XP 3000+
XP 3200+

Athlon64
Athlon64 3200+
Athlon64 FX-51

Opteron
Opteron 240
Opteron 242
Opteron 244
Opteron 246

Memory

Corsair
Crucial
Kingston
Mushkin
OCZ

Search Prices:








































































LOSTCIRCUITS

SHORTCUTS:
Top Page
Dual Channel vs. TwinBank
Behind the Errata
ASUS P4G8X
Features
Layout, VRM
Connectors etc.
BIOS
Setup / Sandra
Expendable, Winstones
3Dmark, Comanche4, UT2003
ViewPerf
Conclusions

Any Comments?

Find the P4G8X online

 ASUS P4G8X Deluxe    
The Black Obelisk
(Review by MS, December 15, 2002)
System Disclosure

Hardware
  • ASUS P4G8X Deluxe Granite Bay Mainboard
  • Intel Pentium4 3.06
  • ATI RADEON 9700
  • 2 x 256 MB Mushkin PC3200 DDR
  • 2 x 512 MB Mushkin PC3200 DDR
  • 2 x 1024 MB Mushkin PC2100 DDR**
  • 1 x 256 MB Corsair PC3200 DDR
  • 1 x 256 MB OCZ PC3200 DDR
  • IBM 60GXP 123 GB
  • Seagate Barracuda SATA-V 30 MB (prototype)
  • Shuttle 52 x CDROM
Software
  • Windows XP Corporate Edition
  • Service Pack 1
  • ATI Catalyst 7.80 drivers
  • SiSoft Sandra 2003
  • Rage Expendable
  • Content Creation Winstone2002
  • Unreal Tournament 2003 Demo
  • SPEC ViewPerf 7.0
  • 3DMark 2001SE
  • Novalogic Comanche4

** using 2 x 1024 MB (1GB DIMMs), SiSoft Sandra did not return any benchmark scores. A single 1G DIMM worked without problems but gave marginally lower scores than a comparable 256 or 512 MB DIMM. All other benchmarks we tried worked flawlessly with 2 x 1 GB DIMMs. We need to mention here that the 1024 MB DIMMs are built using x4 chips that are officially not supported by the chipset. However, the modules are assembled by tying together the address and command pins of the two chips and combining the I/O pins (4 bit + 4 bit) to an 8 bit width seen by the controller. The only chipset we have seen so far that had difficulties with this configuration is the nForce2 chipset. The problem with SiSoft Sandra may simply relate to being confronted with a single 2 GB "ÜberDIMM" which is beyond the current PC convention (limited to 1 GB/DIMM). Since Sandra has to assess the density of the DIMM in order to calculate the appropriate memory space for benchmarking (1/2 of the total system memory) the return of a value beyond what it knows will look wrong and the benchmark will terminate.


Performance

SiSoft Sandra

Of course we were curious how the 128bit mmeory interface affects the overall memory bandwidth available to the CPU. Moreover, since we were boldly claiming on the previous page that there was no support for CAS 1.5 on the DRAM level, we wanted to put proof to the pudding by showing appropriate benchmark results.

SiSoft Sandra memory benchmarks (MB/sec), (buffering enabled) for CAS 1.5, 2 and 2.5 in either single channel (S) or dual channel (D) mode. We know that in DDR the impact of CAS latency is somewhat negligible but we don't believe that there is no difference between CAS-1.5 and CAS-2.5. Still Streaming benchmarks can hide latencies extremely well which is why we turned off prefetching for the next set of benchmark.

SiSoft Sandra memory benchmarks (MB/sec), (buffering disabled) for CAS 1.5, 2 and 2.5 in either single channel (S) or dual channel (D) mode. If prefetching is turned off, we should see some impact of CAS latency on the overall bandwidth, however, the benchmark results are identical for all settings. Changing tRCD from 2 to 3 should show the differences but once again, results were identical for all settings which leaves us with the only possible conclusion that the BIOS settings are, once again, eye candy only and without functionality.


next page:    => ContentCreation Winstone2002 =>

Click here! If you enjoyed reading this article and found it useful, please consider making a small donation to LostCircuits.
Thank you!

General disclaimer: This page only reflects the author's personal opinion and assumes no responsibility whatsoever regarding any of the contents or any damages that may occur explicitly or implicitly from reading the contents of this site. All names and trademarks mentioned in this review are the exclusive property of the respective parent companies.
All contents of this site are protected by international copyright laws. Reproduction of the contents even in parts is not allowed