L O S T C I R C U I T S

| WEB NEWS | Home | Beginners | BBS | CPU | Memory | Mainboard | Network | Video | Tech Advice /
LC-Guides
| Links | Price Guide | SiteMap | Contact | TellUsNews | The LostCircuits RC5 Team! | Poll |
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
 ECS K7S5A (SIS 735 chipset)
The Little Wonder    (Review by MS, August 26 2001)
Top
Specs
Features, Manual, Bundled Software, Quality
Layout, Integrated Peripherals
BIOS
Test Setup, Stability, Synthetic Benchmarks
Expendable, Quake3 Arena, 3DMark2001
Video Editing, Conclusion

The test setup

  • ECS K7S5A mainboard
  • AMD Thunderbird 1.2 G (266 MHz FSB)
  • 1 x Mushkin 512 MB unbuffered PC2100 DDR*
  • 1 x 128 MB Mushkin PC2100 DDR (IBM-based)
  • 1 x 256 MB Crucial PC2100 DDR*
  • 1x 128 MB Corsair PC2400 DDR*
  • 1 x 256 MB Corsair PC2400 DDR*
  • 1 x 128 MB Nanya (Taiwan) PC2100 DDR*
  • 1 x 256 MBMushkin Rev.2
  • MSI Starforce 822 (GeForce3)
  • IBM DTLA 203070 20G HDD
  • ASUS 40x CDROM
  • DLink DFE 10-100T Ethernet adapter
  • Windows98 (first edition)
* all benchmarks were run with 2 x 128 MB DDR DIMMs or 1 x 256 MB SDRAM


Overclocking and Stability

Within specs, the K7S5A is extremely stable, that is, it did not crash a single time during the entire testing period. At 138 MHz and even at 150 MHz the board was running quite stable as well, that is with the caveat, if it was running at all. In all cases, the critical issue was the recognition of the IBM DTLA drive by the BIOS or rather the failure to do so. Changing cables or even drives did not change this pattern that occurred regularly after loading the "Best Performance" setting and then changing BIOS settings or memory configuration. Using a different model, the IBM GXP60 (ER20A44A) the failure did not occur. There are several possibilities for this phenomenon, most likely, the "Best Performance" should be used only with the 100 MHz bus. On the other hand, once the drive was recognized by the BIOS, the error did no longer occur unless the settings were changed again. It could be a glitch of this individual board, a latent compatibility issue with the IBM GXP75 or a simple BIOS glitch but this is as much as we are able of stating at this point.

Performance

One of the domains of the SIS chipset is its non-surplused IDE performance. We used TCDLabs HDTach 2.61 to measure the performance of the IBM DTLA 207050 GPX75 Deskstar. One picture tells more that a thousand words.

One thing is for sure, the SIS chipset does not put any brakes on the IBM drive. Keep in mind that a single drive is unable to take advantage of the MuTIOL interconnect.

SiSoft Sandra Memory Benchmark

We used the 8.21 beta version of Sisoft Sandra to compare the performance with either SDRAM or DDR SDRAM. Settings were "Ultra, Best Performance" CAS latency: 2T, tRAS: 6T, tRP: 3T.

Using SDRAM (shown above), the SIS 735 chipset takes an approximately 30-40% hit in memory bandwidth compared to a DDR configuration (shown below) which seems adequate for Stream applications

=> Expendable, Quake3 Arena, 3DMark2001 =>
BBS | Beginners | Home | Mainboards | CPU | Networking | Memory | Video | Price Guide | Tech Advice


General disclaimer: This page only reflects the author's personal opinion and assumes no responsibility whatsoever regarding any of the contents or any damages that may occur explicitly or implicitly from reading the contents of this site. All names and trademarks mentioned in this review are the exclusive property of the respective parent companies.

All contents of this site are protected by international copyright laws. Reproduction of the contents even in parts is not allowed except after written permission by the author and referral to this site.
Copyright 2001 - 2008 LostCircuits

Click Here!